What are the disadvantages of Medicare Advantage?
An honest list of the trade offs, including the underwriting problem that makes the decision harder to reverse than people expect.
Medicare Advantage works well for a great many people, including most Medicare beneficiaries in this county. That does not mean it is free of drawbacks. Here they are, stated plainly.
Networks limit where you can go
With an HMO, care outside the network is generally not covered except in an emergency. With a PPO it is covered at a higher cost. Either way, your choice of doctor is narrower than it would be under Original Medicare, where any provider accepting Medicare will do.
Networks also change. A hospital system or a physician group can leave a plan at the end of a year, and you find out in the fall paperwork rather than from your doctor.
Prior authorization
Many services require the plan's approval before you receive them. Imaging, skilled nursing stays, some surgeries, some specialty drugs.
Most requests are approved. The cost is delay, paperwork, and occasionally a denial you have to appeal at a moment when you are already unwell. Original Medicare uses prior authorization far less.
Costs are unpredictable in a heavy year
A low or zero premium is genuinely appealing when you are healthy. In a year with a hospitalization, a surgery and rehab, you can pay copays up to the plan's annual out of pocket maximum.
Compare that maximum against a year of supplement premiums before assuming Advantage is cheaper. Sometimes it is, sometimes it is not, and the answer depends entirely on how much care you use.
Coverage is local
Advantage plans are built around a service area. Spend winters elsewhere, travel often, or split time between states and you may find routine care is only covered at home.
Emergencies are covered anywhere. Routine and follow up care usually are not. See how Advantage plans handle travel.
The big one: you may not be able to switch back
You can always leave an Advantage plan and return to Original Medicare. What is not guaranteed is being able to buy the Medicare Supplement that makes Original Medicare affordable.
Your protected Medigap window runs six months from when your Part B begins. During it, no company in Texas can decline you or charge more for your health history. After it closes, they can ask health questions and say no.
This is the asymmetry that matters. Choosing Advantage at 65 is simple. Undoing that choice at 75, after a diagnosis, may not be possible on affordable terms. Nobody is hiding this, but very few people hear it at the moment they are choosing.
Plans change every year
Premiums, copays, drug formularies, networks and extra benefits are all set year by year. The plan you were happy with can look different in January.
This is what the Annual Notice of Change in your fall mail is for, and it is why reviewing every year is not optional. See how to read the ANOC.
Where this leaves you
None of this makes Advantage a bad choice. It makes it a choice with conditions attached, and the conditions are worth understanding while you still have every option open.
If you travel a lot, expect significant medical needs, or want to never think about networks again, look hard at the supplement path. If your doctors are local and in network and the extra benefits matter to you, Advantage is a strong option and the plans here are competitive.
Common follow-up questions
Is Medicare Advantage a scam?
No. These are federally regulated plans that must cover everything Original Medicare covers. The criticism is about network limits, prior authorization and the difficulty of switching back, not about legitimacy.
Can I leave my Advantage plan whenever I want?
You can leave during Annual Enrollment or the Advantage Open Enrollment window from January through March. Returning to Original Medicare is allowed. Buying a supplement afterward may require passing health underwriting.
Do all Advantage plans require prior authorization?
Most use it for at least some services, though the extent varies widely between plans. It is a fair question to ask before enrolling.
Want this looked at properly?
We are an independent agency in McAllen serving Hidalgo, Cameron and Starr counties. No cost to talk it through.
Call (956) 687-3334Read next
What is Medicare Advantage (Part C)?
Medicare Advantage